Video Summary
The VW ID.3 offers a nice, relaxing driving experience. With its 58kWh battery, its range is 266 miles. The ID.3 Pro rides well, and refinements are impressive. The precise handling and clean, responsive steering make it better to drive than the Pro S model. It accelerates smoothly at 7.4 seconds 0-62mph.The MG4 Trophy Extended Range offers 323 miles of range from its 77kWh battery. It is more enjoyable to drive than the VW and the MG has several regenerative braking settings.
The interior of the ID.3 was upgraded. Physical controls have been limited, and the infotainment screen could be better. This car has lots of optional extras, including 19-inch alloy wheels and a panoramic sunroof and is very comfortable.
The MG4's top of the line Trophy has multiple regenerative braking settings.
MG has made a solid effort to make this interesting and fun to drive.
The top-specced Vauxhall Astra Electric gets Vauxhall's AGR-approved front seats.
In contrast to the VW, this car has a range of physical buttons and gets an 10-inch digital cluster on the instrument panel with wireless Apple Carplay.
The Vauxhall Astra Electric is more expensive than the others. The 0-62 time is 9.2 seconds. It is front wheel drive.
MG4 took first place in this test because it's good value for money.
