USA EV Comparison: Tesla Model Y Performance vs Smart #5 Brabus
Struggling to Decide? Let AI Help!
Your AI Summary Is Ready!
General Info
Both vehicles are currently in production. The Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) has a starting price of $57450, while the Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) is not sold in the United States.
The two vehicles share the same body style: SUV.
| Property | Tesla Model Y Performance | Smart #5 Brabus |
|---|---|---|
| Years of Production | 2025-… | 2025-… |
| Current Status | Produced | Produced |
| Country of Manufacture | China, Germany, USA | China |
| Body Style | SUV | SUV |
| Market Availability | EU, USA | EU |
| Price USA (New) | $57450 | - Price USA (New) |
| GCC Score | 7.7 | 7.9 |
Range and Efficiency
Even though the Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) has a larger battery, the Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) higher energy efficiency results in a longer real-world driving range.
| Property | Tesla Model Y Performance | Smart #5 Brabus |
|---|---|---|
| Range (EPA) | 306 mi | - Range (EPA) |
| Range (WLTP) | 360 mi | 336 mi |
| Range (GCC) | 298 mi | 285 mi |
| Battery Capacity (Nominal) | 79 kWh | 100 kWh |
| Battery Capacity (Usable) | 82 kWh | 94 kWh |
| Efficiency per 100 mi | 27.5 kWh/100 mi | 33 kWh/100 mi |
| Efficiency per kWh | 3.63 mi/kWh | 3.03 mi/kWh |
| Range and Efficiency Score | 8.1 | 6.7 |
Charging
The Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) features an advanced 800-volt architecture, whereas the Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) relies on a standard 400-volt system.
The Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) offers faster charging speeds at DC stations, reaching up to 400 kW, while the Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) maxes out at 250 kW.
The Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) features a more powerful on-board charger, supporting a maximum AC charging power of 22 kW, whereas the Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) is limited to 11.5 kW.
| Property | Tesla Model Y Performance | Smart #5 Brabus |
|---|---|---|
| Max Charging Power (AC) | 11.5 kW | 22 kW |
| Max Charging Power (DC) | 250 kW | 400 kW |
| Architecture | 400 V | 800 V |
| Charge Port | Tesla (NACS) | CCS Type 2 |
| Charging Score | 7.2 | 10 |
Performance
Both vehicles are all-wheel drive.
Although the Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) has more power, the Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) achieves a faster 0-60 mph time.
| Property | Tesla Model Y Performance | Smart #5 Brabus |
|---|---|---|
| Drive Type | AWD | AWD |
| Motor Type | IM (front), PMSM (rear) | PMSM (front), PMSM (rear) |
| Motor Power (kW) | 461 kW | 475 kW |
| Motor Power (hp) | 618 hp | 637 hp |
| Motor Torque | 547 lb-ft | 524 lb-ft |
| 0-60 mph | 3.3 s | 3.6 s |
| Top Speed | 155 mph | 130 mph |
| Performance Score | 7 | 6.6 |
Dimensions
The Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) is longer and wider, but the Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) is taller.
Both models have similar wheelbase lengths.
| Property | Tesla Model Y Performance | Smart #5 Brabus |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 188.8 in | 184.8 in |
| Width (with Mirrors) | 83.8 in | 85.4 in |
| Width (w/o Mirrors) | 78 in | 75.6 in |
| Height | 63.4 in | 67.1 in |
| Wheelbase | 113.8 in | 114.2 in |
Cargo and Towing
The Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...) provides more cargo capacity, featuring both a larger trunk and more space with the rear seats folded.
Both models feature a convenient frunk (front trunk), providing additional storage space.
The Smart #5 Brabus (2025-…) is better suited for heavy loads, offering a greater towing capacity than the Tesla Model Y Performance (2025-...).
| Property | Tesla Model Y Performance | Smart #5 Brabus |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Seats | 5 | 5 |
| Curb Weight | 4647 lb | 5242 lb |
| Cargo Volume (Trunk) | 30.2 ft3 | 22.2 ft3 |
| Cargo Volume (Max) | 75.5 ft3 | 54 ft3 |
| Cargo Volume (Frunk) | 4.1 ft3 | 1.7 ft3 |
| Towing Capacity | 3500 lb | 3527 lb |
| Cargo and Towing Score | 7.7 | 7.4 |
