Comparison: Tesla Model Y vs Ford Mustang Mach-E
Since its launch in 2019, the Tesla Model Y has been offered in 5 configurations, each differing in battery, motor power, and drivetrain. In contrast, the Ford Mustang Mach-E, which arrived in 2021, features 9 different variants.
In this comparison we’ll focus on the two most popular configurations: Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD and Ford Mustang Mach-E Extended Range AWD.
Table of Contents
Key Information
Price
The Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD starts at $47,990, making it more affordable than the Ford Mustang Mach-E Extended Range AWD, which has a base price of $52,885.
Exterior
The Ford Mustang Mach-E has a bold, sporty design, reminiscent of the classic Mustang, with a muscular stance and sleek lines. In contrast, the Tesla Model Y features a minimalist, modern design, emphasizing aerodynamics and efficiency.
Interior
The Mach-E comes with a stylish interior that combines practicality and comfort, offering a user-friendly interface and good cargo space. The Model Y boasts a spacious interior with a large touchscreen for controls and a high-tech feel, but some may find the materials less premium.
Technology
Tesla is renowned for its advanced technology, including the Autopilot feature and over-the-air updates. The Mach-E, while it includes modern tech features and an intuitive infotainment system, may not match Tesla's extensive software capabilities.
Range and Efficiency
The Tesla Model Y has a longer range but a significantly smaller battery. In other words, it has a much higher efficiency.
EPA Range
Tesla — 310 mi (499 km)
Ford — 300 mi (483 km)
Battery Pack Capacity (Usable)
Tesla — 75 kWh
Ford — 91 kWh
Charging
The Tesla Model Y and Ford Mach-E are both compatible with overnight home charging via a NEMA 14-50 or NEMA 6-50 outlet, making them equally convenient in this regard. However, Tesla’s faster charging speeds on its 400 V architecture offer a clear advantage. While both EVs can utilize Tesla’s Supercharger network, Ford Mach-E owners will need to use a specialized adapter.
On-Board Charger (AC)
Tesla — 11 kW
Ford — 11 kW
DC Charging
Tesla — 250 kW
Ford — 150 kW
Performance
The Ford Mustang Mach-e offers quicker off-the-line performance, but the Tesla Model Y has a higher top speed.
0–60 mph (0–98 km/h)
Tesla — 4.8 s
Ford — 4.1 s
Top speed
Tesla — 135 mph (217 km/h)
Ford — 111 mph (180 km/h)
Dimensions
While the Tesla Model Y and Ford Mach-E are similar in size, the Ford's extended wheelbase promises improved comfort.
Length
Tesla — 187 in (4,751 mm)
Ford — 185.6 in (4,713 mm)
Width
Tesla — 83.8 in (2,129 mm)
Ford — 82.6 in (2,097 mm)
Wheelbase
Tesla — 113.8 in (2,890 mm)
Ford — 117.5 in (2,984 mm)
Cargo and Towing
With its larger trunk and expanded cargo capacity when seats are folded, the Tesla Model Y outshines the Ford Mach-E. It offers a towing capability of up to 3,500 pounds (≈1,600 kg), unlike the Mach-E, which is not tow-rated in the US. The Model Y also weighs significantly less.
Cargo Volume (Trunk)
Tesla — 30.2 ft³ (856 l)
Ford — 29.7 ft³ (841 l)
Cargo Volume (Max)
Tesla — 72.1 ft³ (2,041 l)
Ford — 59.7 ft³ (1,690 l)
Cargo Volume (Frunk)
Tesla — 4.1 ft³ (116 l)
Ford — 4.7 ft³ (133 l)
Verdict
If you prioritize practicality, efficiency and minimalism, the Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD is an excellent choice. Its longer range, faster charging, and spacious interior make it ideal for daily commutes, family trips, and towing needs. While it may lack the Mustang's sporty appeal, its overall value proposition is hard to beat.
On the other hand, the Ford Mustang Mach-E may appeal to those who value sporty design and a dynamic driving experience. Its sportier design and comfortable interior make it a fun and stylish option. However, its higher price and slightly shorter range may be a consideration for some buyers.
If you're deeply invested in the Tesla ecosystem and value cutting-edge technology, the Model Y is the clear winner. Its advanced Autopilot features, over-the-air updates, and extensive Supercharger network offer a seamless and convenient ownership experience. However, if you prefer a more traditional automotive experience, the Mach-E might be a better fit.
Ultimately, the best choice between the Tesla Model Y and Ford Mustang Mach-E depends on your individual priorities and preferences. Consider your daily driving needs, budget, and desired features to determine which vehicle aligns most closely with your lifestyle.
For a more in-depth comparison of these SUVs, be sure to check out our dedicated comparison tool!
Discussion